COVID-19 Update >> We Are Open 24/7
The Product Lawyers Defective Products Lawyers Logo
A National Alliance Of Products Lawyers
Handling Complex Injury Cases
(877) 671-6480

Philadelphia Transvaginal Mesh Trial Ends In $80 Million Verdict

Doctors In Surgery

A Philadelphia jury has ordered global healthcare giant Johnson & Johnson to pay $80 million in compensation to a Pennsylvania woman injured due to a transvaginal mesh implant. After two days of deliberation, the jury concluded that Ethicon's Prolift vaginal mesh is defective. Ethicon is a subsidiary of Johnson & Johnson.

Learn more about open litigations including Ethicon Physiomesh Lawsuit

Johnson & Johnson Subsidiary Must Pay $80M To Mesh-Injured Woman

This is the latest in a string of jury verdicts rendered over the risks of transvaginal mesh, a type of medical device used in the repair of pelvic organ prolapse, or POP. In court documents, 75-year-old Patricia Mesigian told the harrowing story of what happened after she was implanted with Ethicon's Prolift mesh in 2008. Mesigian claims the mesh began to erode soon after implantation, leading to severe pelvic pain, inflammation and the development of scar tissue.

The $80 million verdict, which includes $50 million in punitive damages, is meant to compensate Mesigian for the suffering she endured at the hands of the Prolift mesh. The compensation is also designed to reimburse the plaintiff for multiple medical procedures; according to the Philadelphia Inquirer, Mesigian underwent "a series of follow-up surgeries," but none proved successful. In her lawsuit, Mesigian accused Ethicon of failing to warn patients about these substantial risks. The Philadelphia jury agreed, ruling that Ethicon had been negligent in drafting patient warnings about the product.

Largest Transvaginal Mesh Award In US History

Thomas R. Kline, Mesigian's attorney, says the $80 million award is the largest compensatory verdict for a victim of transvaginal mesh in American history. "This jury resoundingly found that Johnson & Johnson terribly injured another one of thousands of women implanted with its defective transvaginal mesh device, recognizing not only the severity of the injury but the abhorrence of the conduct," Kline said in a statement emailed to reporters.

J&J Loses Two Consecutive Trials

Even before the $80 million verdict, Johnson & Johnson was already in hot water. In April 2019, a second jury for the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas ordered the company to pay an Altoona woman $120 million in damages. The woman had her mesh implanted to treat incontinence. Johnson & Johnson has already announced its plans to appeal both verdicts. In a statement, Ethicon spokeswoman Mindy Tinsley criticized the jury verdict, saying, "while Ethicon empathizes with women who experience medical complications, this verdict and the damages awarded are inconsistent with the science and Ethicon's actions. The jury was not permitted to hear critical evidence related to the FDA's review and classification of these devices, which we believe significantly influenced the verdict and punitive award in the case."

Mesh Under Fire From American Regulators

Transvaginal mesh has already led to a flashpoint in American medical history. Mesh products designed for the treatment of pelvic organ prolapse, a condition in which weakened pelvic muscles allow organs to fall below their normal position, have resulted in tens of thousands of product liability lawsuits against a number of medical device manufacturers. Transvaginal mesh now represents one of the largest mass torts in US legal history.

And it appears that regulators are finally taking the hint. In a major decision announced in July 2019, the US Food & Drug Administration revoked the certifications for two pelvic mesh products. These products, which can no longer be sold in the United States, were the last remaining pelvic mesh products on the market. By removing the last two remaining pelvic mesh products from the American market, the FDA has made it effectively impossible to acquire the products.

Meet Our Transvaginal Mesh Attorneys

Were you or a loved one injured by transvaginal mesh? Our experienced personal injury attorneys are here to help. We understand your situation, and we know what to do next. You may be eligible to pursue valuable financial compensation by filing a private civil lawsuit. Join the thousands of other women who have stood up to demand justice.

This is the time to fight back. Our attorneys understand the pain and suffering you've been forced to endure. Our only goal is to see justice done. You can trust us to pursue your case. Our firm has gained considerable experience in pursuing pelvic mesh litigation. Our attorneys have already secured nearly $15 million in compensation for transvaginal mesh survivors.

Contact our attorneys today to learn more in a free, confidential consultation. Our mission is to ensure that your rights are protected. Our payment structure is designed to reflect this fact. Our attorneys work on a contingency-fee basis, which means that you pay us nothing unless we secure compensation in your case. You have nothing to lose, and everything to gain.

Continue Reading: California Man Files Class Action Over Arsenic In Bottled Water

Do You Qualify?

  • Contact Info
  • Case Details

Free Case Evaluation

Call Today
24/7 Helpline
Free Consults
Get Justice
(877) 671-6480
Laurence Banville
Date Published: June 25, 2019
Contact Our Consumer Advocates Today
Call Our 24/7 Recalled Products Helpline Now
(877) 671-6480
© 2020 All rights reserved. is primarily sponsored by Banville Law, PLLC, a New York-based law firm, with attorneys licensed to practice law in the state of New York. and the District of Columbia. is an alliance of attorneys across the United States who dedicate their professional careers to representing individuals who were seriously injured by defective products, drugs and medical devices. This website is to be considered ATTORNEY ADVERTISING. Past settlement and verdict values are no guarantee of similar future outcomes. is not a law firm. has a team of consumer advocates who can help connect consumers or patients to members of the alliance who are experienced in a specific type of case for a free legal consultation.

SitemapDisclaimer / Terms Of Service & Privacy Policy